Book Review: Eggshells by Caitriona Lally

Eggshells – Caitriona Lally (Melville House Publishing, 2018)

Vivian lives alone in the city of Dublin, inhabiting her great-aunt’s house after said great-aunt’s death. The house is fusty, crowded, and has too many chairs. But it suits Vivian who is what we might call “an odd duck”. Very soon after the book opens we watch Vivian divide some of her aunt’s ashes into envelopes to be addressed and sent to twenty-two friends from her aunt’s address book. Preferring the alphabetical symmetry of twenty-six, Vivian also chooses four strangers’ addresses from the phone book.

Each day Vivian walks from her house (avoiding her gossipy neighbours) and charts a route around Dublin. She interacts very little with others and the interactions she does have with strangers are uncomfortable and confused. Vivian is searching for a portal, an entry into another world. Vivian believes she is a changeling and is searching for the way back to her true home. At one point she decides she wants a friend named Penelope and so advertises for one (by putting a notice up on a tree). It doesn’t take long for her to make a Penelope friend and the two women have several encounters together.

The book’s blurb seems to suggest that this friendship with Penelope is the plot line of the novel but that actually happens quite early one and with relatively little fanfare. Penelope is, predictably, also odd but in a different way than Vivian. This helps the two women to accept each others’ quirks but doesn’t enable them to really help each other in any way.

There really is very little plot here. We follow Vivian around Dublin and, with her as our first person narrator, we see the world in a slightly new way. Vivian notices things and is both very observant and extremely obtuse. Her interactions with her sister (also named Vivian) are skin-crawlingly uncomfortable to read because our Vivian has no idea how others perceive her. Her world makes sense to her but she is, in many ways, barely functioning within our world.

She is charming in many ways; I particularly enjoyed all the lists she kept – items at a museum, types of cake, names of butterflies – she enjoys words and takes notice of the ways words fit together. She hides money in the pockets of sweaters at a thrift store in order to brighten a strangers’ day. She writes mysterious notes in books before she gives them away in order to create a story that she will not be part of. And although I’m not familiar with the city of Dublin, through Vivian, Caitriona Lally brings the city to life in a way that I imagine is wonderful for anyone who has spent time there.

In the end, I was left wanting more. I had hoped for a climax or a conclusion because that is what we hope for from novels. Yet, I can’t help but feel that Lally’s choice to not create a happy ending (or even an ending) for Vivian is the most honest one. There have been several of these quirky, maybe-on-the-spectrum, type narrators in books in the past few years (Eileen and Eleanor Oliphant both came to mind) These stories and characters are often presented as quirky and funny but there’s none of that with Vivian. Vivian isn’t funny. Vivian is clearly a woman on the fringe of society who is barely getting by. Who is missing out on companionship and support and whose problems aren’t solved at the end of book. And sadly, this is the truth for many people like Vivian. I wanted a happy ending because that’s what I wanted for Vivian but by refusing to satisfy that desire, Lally has actually created a more powerful story.

7 thoughts on “Book Review: Eggshells by Caitriona Lally”

  1. I hadn’t heard of this one but it sounds interesting! I really liked Eleanor Oliphant, and Vivan’s character sounds similarly compelling to me, but the lack of plot would probably not work for me at all even if it makes sense for the sort of character study this is. Books that meander around without a clear direction just never tend to hold my attention well, unfortunately! It does sound like a great story for the right reader, though.

    1. There are definitely similarities to Eleanor. But without more of an outside world around Vivian this seems more like a character study than a linear novel. Which is well done but definitely not for everyone.

    2. I’m with Emily. Even if the tension is whether Vivian will find her Penelope, that’s enough for me. I don’t need a huge hobbit journey, or something. But if there’s nothing that has me asking, “What will happen next? How will X resolve?” then I have no reason to pick the book up. I know there was a trend with small-press authors of a certain group who, for a while, would just have these wandering novellas that really did nothing other than emphasize that millennials feel they have no purpose.

      However, the way that Vivian is not made to be “quirky” appeals to me. I don’t like when authors take a person with mental or physical disabilities and avoid the hard stuff. I’ve heard some folks say they feel austism is like a superpower (Greta Thunberg being the most famous), but that doesn’t mean they just “cute,” “quirky,” or whatever. Overall, this book intrigues me but the plotlessness would drive me bonkers!

    3. It’s very much more of a character study. I guess Vivian is on a personal journey to return back to where she “belongs” but the reader knows this is obviously a fruitless task. I did really appreciate that she isn’t quirky at all. The book has funny parts but Vivian herself isn’t funny and we aren’t meant to laugh at her or enjoy her differences. It’s uncomfortable in the way that interactions with strangers can be really uncomfortable (and Lally really captures this in some of Vivian’s interactions with strangers). I can’t think of a lot of books that have done this successfully so I appreciate that here but overall the book is rather a hard sell!

  2. I’d react much as you did with this story; wanting a happy ending because those are more pleasant to read, but fully aware that happy endings don’t happen for everyone; neither do complete endings. Sometimes life just…quietly finishes for some people, and that’s life, as sad as it sounds.

    1. Yes, it left me with a lot of mixed feelings. Vivian is capable of living on her own but barely so in many ways and it left me feeling quite sad about how many people there are like this in our society and how little there is to assist them.

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s