Book Review: If I Had Your Face by Frances Cha

If I Had Your Face – Frances Cha (Ballantine Books, 2020)

This was an easy-to-read and compelling, if somewhat flawed novel. Following five women who live in an apartment building in Seoul, Korea, it shines a light on the lives of young people, the disparity between the rich and the poor, and the Korean beauty industry.

Kyuri is a room salon girl, a beautiful young woman who makes a living in an underground salon where she sits and drinks with wealthy men, and sometimes sleeps with them. Her roommate Miho is an artist, abandoned by her family as a child she grew up to receive a scholarship and studied in the US. Now back in Korea she is haunted by the memories of a former friend and the complications of her current relationship with a much richer man. Ara is mute, silenced in a traumatic incident and obsessed with a K-Pop star. She exists in a sort of suspended childhood but also shows more wisdom than some of the other girls. Her roommate and childhood friend is Sujin, completely focused with changing her physical appearance so that she too can become a room salon girl. Wonna is our fifth character, on the outside of this quartet. She lives in the same building but is slightly older, married, desperate to become a mother but existing on the verge of poverty and also haunted by an unhappy childhood.

In fact, Kyuri is the only one still in contact with her mother, who has no idea what her real job is. This serves to show the widening divide between generations, how the younger generation has no desire for marriage or parenthood, flocking instead to the city where they strive for dreams always just out of reach.

Beauty is central to the novel. The power of it, how to gain it, and what it doesn’t provide. Kyuri is described as stunningly beautiful but her beauty is a result of major surgery and continued and involved upkeep. At the beginning of the novel Sujin has jaw surgery in order to reshape her face. Miho is described as naturally beautiful but mostly unaware of her own physical body and largely uncaring of her looks.

While the book is interesting and didn’t take me long to read, it felt like it was missing something. The girls each had an interesting backstory that was slowly revealed in their various sections but the present day action was somewhat minimal and what there was felt so inevitable that there was very little surprise in what happened. With the exception of Miho, none of the women seemed to change very much from the beginning to end. Their circumstances were not vastly different at the conclusion of the novel. While I don’t require every book character to learn a Grand Lesson, I did wonder why Cha chose this segment of time in these characters lives.

Overall though I appreciated the different lifestyle and culture. Both that of Korea and this beauty culture that was totally foreign to me. While uneven, there is also lots of potential here and I look forward to reading more of Cha’s work.

15 thoughts on “Book Review: If I Had Your Face by Frances Cha”

  1. I would have thought the book would delve deeply into the beauty expectations for Korean women. I know there are still issues with skin bleaching and altering the eye so it isn’t hooded, etc. I’d love to read a novel that really delves into the beauty regimens of women in an Asian country. I mostly know about American women (black, white, and latinx).

    1. I thought it would too. I’ve seen the ads for skin bleaching etc in China. Surgery is fairly central to the novel – the eyelid alteration and the jaw reshaping but it doesn’t delve into all that as much as I expected. It was actually a lot more about women’s roles and generational shifts which was interesting but it could have gone deeper into that, I think.

  2. I loved this book but I definitely understand your criticisms! It did feel a little incomplete unfortunately – I would have liked at least another 150 pages, which is not a feeling I am often left with.

    1. Yes, when I realized I was getting close to the end I was surprised because it felt like not enough had happened. I did enjoy the book and I liked how different the characters were than so many others I’ve read, it just felt incomplete to me.

    1. You should read it! I definitely don’t want to stop anyone who is interested. I did enjoy it and it only took me a couple of days to read, it was just kind of uneven for me.

  3. This book sounds really fascinating to me; the culture that obsesses over beauty is an interesting one, and seeing as I haven’t changed of out of my sweatpants in two weeks, probably something I should try to strive a bit more towards LOL

    1. It’s definitely an entirely different culture from what I’m used to (even before when we used to leave our houses and see each other and stuff).

  4. Great review! It’ll be good to keep in mind that this isn’t necessarily a perfect read, but it does sound very appealing- I’m adding it to my TBR!

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s