Book Review: Molly of the Mall by Heidi L.M. Jacobs

Molly of the Mall – Heidi L.M. Jacobs (NeWest Press, 2020)

Molly MacGregor is in her early twenties, a student of literature at the University of Alberta in Edmonton. The year is 1995 and Molly has taken a full-time summer job at Le Petit Chou Shoe Shop in “the mall”. We follow Molly through her summer job – the ups and downs of being a purveyor of fine shoes – and the following year of student life. Molly is the a lover of Jane Austen, the daughter of two university professors, and a creative student. She and her older siblings (Tess and Heathcliff) were given their names based on their father’s syllabus and as Molly struggles to read Moll Flanders for the first time she wonders what it means to be named in honour of such a character.

The story is told from Molly’s perspective, almost in journal entries, as she examines the world around her and her interactions with friends, family, co-workers, and a mysterious fellow book lover she knows only as The Penguin Man. We are given insights into some of Molly’s school assignments as well, which are done in very creative ways. Molly is also a music lover and there are plenty of 1995-appropriate music references.

In fact, when I initially read the synopsis for Molly of the Mall, I didn’t think I was the right age to be nostalgic for this era. I was in elementary school in 1995 yet I never felt lost by Molly’s references. While I might associate Alan Rickman more with Harry Potter than an object of romance, Wonderwall was just as seminal a song in my teen years as it is for Molly.

What I enjoyed most about this novel though was just how unapologetically Canadian it is. From toques to Big Rock beer to the dark afternoons of the winter, Molly’s life felt like a wonderfully familiar glimpse into a Canadian life. I don’t know Edmonton well and I’ve only visited West Edmonton Mall once (in 1998, so close to Molly’s time there) but Jacobs’ descriptions felt accurate to what I know. Molly’s journals are particularly evocative of the unique stage of life that being a university student is. Filled with so many unknowns and possibilities, challenging but thrilling.

This was a really fun, very funny, delightfully Canadian book.

13 thoughts on “Book Review: Molly of the Mall by Heidi L.M. Jacobs”

  1. This DOES sound fun, but all the Canadian references would be lost on me. I am totally delighted, though, that the store is called Chou Shoe. And of course, my brain inserted, “Chugga Chugga Chou Shoe!”

    1. I think you’d really enjoy this! You could definitely read it without getting the Canadian references but they do make it extra fun. And if you’ve ever worked retail, the scenes in the shoe store are especially hilarious!

    2. That’s interesting and kind of unusual! I feel like working at a library might give you a similar experience with regards to working with the general public. Just without the pressure to sell them things!

  2. Haha, I love the father’s choice of names for his children – do you think he hated them? Being two-thirds of the way through Wuthering Heights at the moment, I’m particularly horrified that anyone would call their son Heathcliff… 😱

    1. Actually, in the book they want to name their second child Cathy and so he puts Wuthering Heights on the syllabus for around his wife’s due date. But then they have a boy! It’s definitely a joke in the book that they’re all named after kind of terrible characters!

    1. I think you’d really enjoy this! It recently won the Stephen Leacock award. I didn’t receive this is an advance either, this was on loan from my mother-in-law. I don’t know if I would have gravitated to it on my own.

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s