Book Review: The Daughters of Foxcote Manor by Eve Chase

The Daughters of Foxcote Manor – Eve Chase (G.P. Putnam’s Sons, 2020)

I received an Uncorrected Proof of this book. All opinions are my own.

Rita was hired as a nanny for the wealthy Harrington family, to care for angsty, adolescent Hera, rambunctious young Teddy, and the new baby due soon. It was her dream job, working for the glamorous family in London but when tragedy strikes, Rita ends up at Foxcote Manor, the Harringtons’ forest home, with Hera and Teddy and their mother Jeannie, recently returned from a stay at The Lawns after a nervous breakdown. There is no new baby and instead Rita has been tasked by Jeannie’s husband Walter to take notes on his wife.

This part of the story is told mostly from Rita’s perspective but with insights also from Hera, who loves her mother and resents her family and suspects that things were not as straightforward as she’s been told the night her baby sister was born.

Alternating with this 1970s-set story is the the modern day story of Sylvie, a forty-something woman newly separated from her husband. Her 18-year-old daughter Annie is resentful of the impending divorce and Sylvie’s mother has recently suffered an accident that leaves her in a coma. Sylvie has a history of not confronting the past but Annie is beginning to dig and together they are forced to look more deeply at Sylvie’s origins.

This was an entertaining read. The characters are all likeable and easy to follow. It isn’t particularly difficult to see where the connection between the two timelines lies and most of the reveals are easy to spot well before they are spelled out. The couple of “twists” that I didn’t predict seemed pretty farfetched, there simply to tie a very neat (and rather unrealistic) bow on the end of the story.

The core of the novel is mother-daughter relationships and what that entails. What makes that relationship a significant one and why does it exist? Is it about blood connection? Is it about care or sacrifice? Rita is the nanny but cares for Hera and Teddy deeply and is more present and aware for the children than their own parents are. But how much will she sacrifice for them? How much should she when their own parents can take them away at any moment?

The book seems to be marketed as a thriller but I’m not sure it truly is. While there’s definitely some mystery here, I never felt a lot of tension. The stakes never felt that high to me and it seemed like no matter how things turned out, the characters would probably be fine. The setting of the forest and the long-forgotten manor is clearly supposed to be ominous but for me Chase never succeeded in making me feel like the forest was a truly dangerous place. Perhaps a reader who went into this book with a fear of trees would feel differently but I actually read the novel while camping in the woods and even that didn’t create any unease for me.

I haven’t read any of Eve Chase’s previous novels though it appears that she favours mansions in the woods and dual timelines. While overall entertaining, The Daughters of Foxcote Manor isn’t a particularly strong offering and I have to wonder if her previous works might be more thrilling.

13 thoughts on “Book Review: The Daughters of Foxcote Manor by Eve Chase”

    1. It was still an overall enjoyable read but I think someone looking for a truly thrilling or creepy story would be disappointed.

  1. I’m still not a fan of dual timelines, and I don’t seem to have it in me to pick up a book that utilizes this technique. I wonder if it’s going to be trendy for a while, or if it will fade away.

    1. It’s definitely a trend right now. A lot of the time it seems to be used solely to flesh out a story and it feels really unnecessary (in my opinion.) In this case, the real drama of the story is definitely in the 1970s plot but Sylvie was a likeable enough character for the present timeline that I didn’t care too much. I predict it will slowly fade away as a trend though.

  2. Great review! It is a bummer when books marketed as thrillers really don’t feel very high stakes or even particularly atmospheric, but I’m glad you found it entertaining at least. Perhaps I’ll keep an eye out for this author and see if another of her books might seem better suited to me- in addition to wanting a bigger thrill like you mention, I am a bit oversaturated with mother-daughter books this year!

    1. Thanks! I don’t know if I’m curious enough to read any of her other books but I’m interested to know how similar they are since the descriptions sound like very much the same set up.

      I could see another reader finding the setting more spooky too. I live in a very forested area and spend a fair amount of time amongst trees so it’s hard to convince me that they’re creepy. Maybe a reader from the prairie would feel differently?

    2. That makes sense. Comparisons can be interesting, but too much similarity can be tedious sometimes as well.

      My first instinct as a prairie-dweller was to say I don’t find trees particularly creepy either, but actually I do feel unsettled being in wooded areas at night! It’s an unusual setting for me so perhaps that does make it more frightening. It would have to be very convincing writing though I think, for a fictional forest to give me that same feeling.

  3. I appreciated your honest review of this book. It’s a shame it isn’t more thrilling than it appears, since I might have picked it up otherwise! And based off the cover, I initially thought it was women’s fiction—there was something whimsical about the ivy-covered brick wall.

    1. It could probably fall under women’s fiction quite easily but it does seem to want to be classed as a thriller. Perhaps a change in marketing would benefit it!

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s