(Audio) Book Review: A Place for Us by Fatima Farheen Mirza

A family is brought together to celebrate a wedding. Rafiq and Layla are celebrating the wedding of their firstborn, their daughter Hadia, who is marrying for love unlike their own arranged marriage. Rafiq and Layla met only a few times before their marriage, when Layla left her home and moved to the United States to be with her new husband. Together they have built a family and community. Hadia, is a leader, a people pleaser, in many ways the glue that holds their family together. It is their youngest child, their only son, Amar, who seems to threaten to pull the family apart. At Hadia’s request, Amar is returning home for her wedding, the first time in three years that the family will have all been together.

The story moves between the third person perspectives of Hadia, Layla, and Amar (and then a section at the end from Rafiq’s perspective). We see scenes from Layla’s early years as a young wife in a new country, married to a man she hardly knows. We see Hadia and Amar’s childhood, their close relationship and the struggles they face as children of immigrants in America, particularly as Muslims. (There is a middle child, a daughter Huda, who we never get a close view of.)

The sibling relationships here are very well done as is the exploration of the family dynamic. The differences between generations – some due to personality, some due to culture shifts – feel real. The characters are each flawed but drawn so realistically that it was always easy to sympathize with each one and understand what was driving their actions.

Personally, I really appreciated the portrayal of a deeply religious family that is experiencing a shift between generations. As Hadia and Amar (and Huda too, probably) grow up and become adults their understanding of what it is to be Muslim – and Muslim in America – shifts and develops and looks different from what their parents’ expectations might be. We see Hadia come of age to cover her hair and wear a scarf. And then we see her remove it after 9/11 and her father’s fear for her in its aftermath. We see Amar struggle with substance abuse and wonder where his place might be in his family and in a religion that forbids all intake of alcohol. We see Rafiq’s understanding of his own religion grow as he struggles to adapt to what he sees as his children’s rebellion.

A note on the audio version: This was my first audio book! I mean, not really, I used to listen to stories on tape as a kid, but it was my first time searching for a book off my TBR List and listening to it in audio format. I mostly listened while walking or doing housework which worked out pretty well for me. I found the plot easy to follow and didn’t have trouble distinguishing between characters. The first part of the novel is narrated by Deepti Gupta and I found her voice just right. I appreciated being able to hear the accurate pronounciation of names and Urdu words used throughout the book. She uses slightly different accents to distinguish between characters and, again, I felt like this made sense to show that someone like Layla would still have an accent, while Hadia who was born in the US would not. The last part of the book is narrated by Sunil Malhotra. I did not know there was going to be a switch and so was very surprised when suddenly a man’s voice showed up in my ear. The change in narrator makes sense for the content of the book but I didn’t like it as much. Maybe I had simply grown attached to the first narrator but I also found the way Malhotra voiced women and children to be awkward. It felt like he was putting on a voice, if that makes sense.

9 thoughts on “(Audio) Book Review: A Place for Us by Fatima Farheen Mirza”

  1. Woohoo! Glad you enjoyed your first audiobook! I usually prefer when they stick with one narrator too – when there are two, one always ends up feeling less good than the other, and they usually give different voices to the same characters which is irritating. The exception was Dracula with Greg Wise and Saskia Reeves, who I felt had both worked hard together to keep the same kind of voice for the characters that appeared in both their sections.

    1. So far I’m just choosing what’s available through my library’s app so I’m kind of at their mercy but this turned out to be a good start. I could see how the change in narrator here was meant to reflect the shift in focus within the novel but it was so unexpected to suddenly have a man’s voice in my ear! And, as you say, it’s impossible not to compare them and have one you prefer.

  2. Welcome to the world of audiobooks! So glad you enjoyed this one, and yes, I agree that having the narrator suddenly shift is confusing. I don’t mind so much if there is a good reason for alternating chapters (e.g. two characters’ point-of-view) but in general I prefer there to be one narrator throughout.

    1. Thanks! I am already learning what works for me and what doesn’t, which is interesting. I think multiple voice actors (more like a radio play, I guess) would be interesting but the sudden switch was jarring.

  3. I’ve never listened to an audio book myself, but you are inspiring me! Because I have so little knowledge of them, I’m shocked that the narrator changed halfway through. The reviews I’ve read of audiobooks have literally never mentioned that, unless the book included a BUNCH of actors, but I think that’s different. It almost sounds like a mistake on the producer’s part LOL

    1. I never had time before! But now that I am going to and from work on my own it’s a nice way to fill that time and get extra reading in. I also will put an audio book on while cooking or folding laundry or any of those mundane tasks when I’m home alone.

  4. If anyone is wondering where to start with audiobooks, I do think a full-cast novel can be a great beginning. Neil Gaiman’s Neverwhere has one. This post reminded me that I used to work with a woman from India who married a man from Nashville, TN, and wow, that was such a funny pairing that I truly enjoyed their company. Her sister and parents had arranged marriages. I do think that an arranged marriage is not a terrible idea if both people are kind and feel like they are entering a partnership. Sometimes we’re so picky about dating that we pass up great people because of one small thing. Yet, if the marriage is entered with the assumption that the man is gaining a wife, I don’t see how that can work. That’s more like acquiring property.

    1. India and Nashville! That does sound like an unlikely pairing! Many of my friends in high school had parents who had arranged marriages. I know of a couple of my classmates who went that route but it was very uncommon amongst those who were born here in Canada. If it’s what you want, I don’t think arranged marriages are a bad thing. Though of course there is a lot of history of it being little better than sex trafficking for young girls. But in a situation where everyone involved is well-meaning, I think it can be a thoughtful way to find a life partner. And of course now even in arranged marriages the couple isn’t just meeting on the day of their wedding!

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s